Loading Bars

Now with 3.0 goodness 
« Back to blog

Safari 4 Loading Bar

Noticed something about the new loading bar in Safari 4.
 
Well, first of all, it's has a different look from the one presented in Safari 4 public beta. In the beta it's just a rotating set of bars at the edge of the address bar. In the final version it's a rotating set of bars on a button near the end of the address bar.
 
In Safari 3, to let you know that a page is being loaded, the address bar gets filled up with an incremental blue bar that tells you how much of the page has been loaded. For me this was helpful in situations when my connection is flaky and I need to know roughly whether it has stalled or not or how much to go.
 
For whatever reason, the Safari team at Apple thinks this blue bar is junk and decided to do away with it, replacing it with a button that shows a different shade of gray depending on what is loading. Looks like I'll have to hit the webkit blogs to find out if they explain it there.

 

Update: I remember reading a response on Twitter from Maciej Stachowiak, WebKit Developer, regarding the removal of the blue bar from Safari some time ago so I went to search for it and found it. He said, "The big blue progress bar led to users waiting for mostly-loaded and usable pages. Removing it makes browsing effectively faster." I'm not entirely sure how he came to that conclusion, most of the times when the blue bar hasn't finished loading the page remains blank. Mobile Safari, even on iPhone OS 3.0 still uses that blue bar.

 

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (10)

Jun 10, 2009
Aayush Arya said...
As soon as someone finds a way to bring back the blue loading bar in Safari 4, I’m jumping in with headfirst. Tabs on top and these silly replacements for the blue progress indicator were the worst two “additions” to Safari 4 beta. I’m glad that Apple did away with one of them but saddened that they fancied it up and left the other one in.
Jun 10, 2009
Aayush Arya said...
That was supposed to be “…I’m jumping in headfirst.” Pardon the typo.
Jun 10, 2009
anima said...
I personally like the new loading bar. prettier.
Jun 10, 2009
Aulia Masna said...
@anima but it doesn't tell me how much longer to wait before it loads completely
Jun 10, 2009
bluedoggiant said...
He is exactly right. In a way, this added a feature for me, when its blue, it means the page has not even loaded, so if you click X, you will still remain on the same page you are on, however if you click X while it is white, that means parts of the page have already loaded, making it usable.
Jun 11, 2009
jibeng said...
I think people with boardbrand internet won't miss Safari's loading bar. Sadly broadband in Indonesia is quite narrow.
Jun 12, 2009
The Red King said...
Please, please, please, bring back the blue loading bar. It was a simple thing that separated Safari from other browsers.
Jun 12, 2009
It looks cool.
Jun 24, 2009
pavlo Soteriou said...
I downloaded safari 4 and was very frustrated with it because I could never tell whether a page was making progress or whether it was just stalled. I re-installed Safari 3. I won't be installing Safari 4 unless and until the blue bar is re-instated.
Aug 12, 2009
Malcolm said...
This is so annoying! I have a forum that I visit daily, and I make good use of opening multiple threads in different tabs. Sometimes the pages will all look blank with the loading bar absent. As I begin to click and reload some pages, I see that the others were actually loading with no indication of progress. However, other times the pages really are stopped, and I waste time waiting for the phantom loading to occur!

Leave a comment...

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter